133 [S10 E5] The Mess and the Magic: from the good girl narrative to autistic self compassion
Description
Dr Michelle McQuaid is a wellbeing researcher in her early 50s. She lives and works in Melbourne, Australia, where she is an honorary fellow at Melbourne University's Center for Wellbeing Science. Michelle was diagnosed autistic nearly ten years ago, after her then five year old son was diagnosed.
By then, Michelle's autistic brain had turned perfectionism into an all-consuming mission, and by 34 this relentless intensity ended in burnout. She had assumed a 'good girl' persona - perfect performance, constant people-pleasing, and protecting others at any cost - and, as she puts it, turning herself into "a human ATM of generosity".
For Michelle, an autism diagnosis wasn't just an explanation – it was liberation. Understanding her autistic brain helped her recognise that her patterns weren't personal failings, but the result of trying to force her neurodivergent brain into a neurotypical world. This realisation transformed how she navigates both her autism and the 'good girl' expectations, by uncovering evidence-based practices we can all use.
In this conversation we talk about burnout, masking and self-compassion. We explore the impact of societal expectations on autistic women, the concept of the 'good girl' and how Michelle learned to embrace her autistic traits and developed strategies for understanding her neurodiversity and practices that can transform the way we see ourselves and the lives we build.
Squarepeg is a podcast in which I talk to other late identified autistic women and nonbinary people about their lives, their autism journeys, and what they've learned along the way.
I'm Amy Richards, and I was diagnosed autistic in 2016, when I was 37. I've been sharing my conversations with other autistic adults since 2020.
I hope you'll find these conversations inspiring and thought provoking, and that they'll help you feel more connected to a worldwide community of people with similar experiences.
➡️LISTEN AD-FREE WHEN YOU BECOME A PATREON SUPPORTER
https://www.patreon.com/squarepegpodcast
EPISODE LINKS:
Good Girl resources: https://www.thegoodgirlgamechangers.com
Website: https://www.michellemcquaid.com/
The Perfectly Imperfect Little Girl: https://michellemcquaid.substack.com/p/buy-now-the-perfectly-imperfect-books
The Ordinary Princess: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Ordinary-Princess-Puffin-Book/dp/0141361166
Character strengths: https://www.viacharacter.org/
If you'd like to connect with me, get in touch or follow Squarepeg, you can find me on:
Website: https://squarepeg.community/
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/squarepegpodcast
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/squarepeg.community/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/squarepegautism/
THANK YOU TO MY PATRONS!
A HUGE thank you to my amazing patrons, who support my work on the podcast:
Abi Hunter, Alex, Alex Lee, Alice Kemp, Amy Adler, Anika Lacerte, Anna Grojec, Annette, Annie, Anya Nebl, Aubrey Brand, B Martinez, Barbara, Basia, Becca Lee, Becky Beasley, Ben Davies, Beth Kelly Herbert, Caprice, Caroline, Cat Preston, Catherine, Cathy Oliver, C B, Charlotte Keen, Claire Gerard, Corinne Cariad, Corrine L. McDermid, Dana, Dana Bradley, Danielle Warby, Danielle Wrench, Daphna Epstein, Deaborah, Deanna M. Counts Goldy, Dennis McNulty, E, Em, Emma Franks, Erica Kenworthy, Erin Mazow, Evgeniia Pupysheva, Ewan McNeill, Frederike, Galina, George Cole, H Arena, Hannah Breslin, Heather Peake, Helen Anne Hooker, Helen Delaney, Helen White, Holly Knight-Smith, India, Jackie Allen, Jaqueline Coursey, Jayne Hutchinson, Jenn W, Jo, Joanna McKnight, Julie, Julie Gillespie, Karen, Karin Parker, KatF, Kate and Kathryn, Katharine Richards, Katherine, Katherine Meizel, Ken K, Kim Mortstock, Laura, Laura, Laurin Aman, Lilli Simmons, Lisa, Lisa Joy Powley, Lisa Williams, Liz, Lizzie, Lula Cork, Mandy Allen, Marjory Webber, Martha Everett, Meg c, Melissa Shaw, Meredith L. Freyre, Mindy Wigzell, Monica Toohey, NC, Nicola Neil, Pete Burke, Rebecca, Rebecca Biegel, Sadie Slater, Sandra Chapman, Sandy Klarsten, Sandy Ladkin, Sarah Ivinson, Sarah Jeffrey, Sarah LW, Sarah Musgrave, Sarah Raine, Shelia Smith, Sophie King, Talia's Nature,Tamsen Staniford, Tris, Vicki Temple, Victoria Jeffrey and Zans McLachlan.
If you're enjoying the Squarepeg podcast and would like to help me carry on making new episodes, you can become a member of the Squarepeg community on Patreon from £3 per month: https://www.patreon.com/squarepegpodcast

![133 [S10 E5] The Mess and the Magic: from the good girl narrative to autistic self compassion 133 [S10 E5] The Mess and the Magic: from the good girl narrative to autistic self compassion](https://s3.castbox.fm/eb/41/7d/43dbf9c6a61bc5e900e6c795f58be85f2a_scaled_v1_400.jpg)
![140 [S10 E12] Working with autism, not against: Mental health, masking and giving ourselves grace 140 [S10 E12] Working with autism, not against: Mental health, masking and giving ourselves grace](https://s3.castbox.fm/b5/61/73/747e27f2c720a1a00be87b6ef938308a4e_scaled_v1_400.jpg)
![139 [S10 E11] Creating space to show up without shrinking: how we can thrive at work as autistics 139 [S10 E11] Creating space to show up without shrinking: how we can thrive at work as autistics](https://s3.castbox.fm/45/38/60/c526ce9f05448cdb89d434fad5f4a86081_scaled_v1_400.jpg)
![138 [S10 E10] Working with our ocean and our tides: the impact of autism self identification 138 [S10 E10] Working with our ocean and our tides: the impact of autism self identification](https://s3.castbox.fm/7c/26/ea/abf41edb502b7516c19a58b32562571fd2_scaled_v1_400.jpg)
![137 [S10 E9] Meeting myself again: sensory needs, autistic joys and building stronger relationships after autism diagnosis 137 [S10 E9] Meeting myself again: sensory needs, autistic joys and building stronger relationships after autism diagnosis](https://s3.castbox.fm/ce/55/3b/e23951b23d4692135be2c661be922c8496_scaled_v1_400.jpg)
![136 [S10 E8] 'Undercover autistic': shaping a more just and inclusive future for autistic care users & practitioners 136 [S10 E8] 'Undercover autistic': shaping a more just and inclusive future for autistic care users & practitioners](https://s3.castbox.fm/01/89/8e/26314c48ba901ae9d85ed2b9b98709f328_scaled_v1_400.jpg)
![135 [S10 E7] A blessing and a curse: autism, masking and miscommunication 135 [S10 E7] A blessing and a curse: autism, masking and miscommunication](https://s3.castbox.fm/de/1c/a1/b03d574e915147ab03867012a86c9b61e6_scaled_v1_400.jpg)
![134 [S10 E6] Making your body a nicer place to live: autism and a different approach to physical fitness 134 [S10 E6] Making your body a nicer place to live: autism and a different approach to physical fitness](https://s3.castbox.fm/32/be/91/dfa0048c24f8bf7b16a4d1166191a7b38d_scaled_v1_400.jpg)
![132 [S10 E4] "Layers of unravelling": autism, leadership and belonging with Kirsty Cullen-Campanelli 132 [S10 E4] "Layers of unravelling": autism, leadership and belonging with Kirsty Cullen-Campanelli](https://s3.castbox.fm/6a/ff/f4/943c9f22dc0665bb04b790157e4eb66a77_scaled_v1_400.jpg)
![131 [S10 E3] Working at the edge of what we know: autism, trauma and identity 131 [S10 E3] Working at the edge of what we know: autism, trauma and identity](https://s3.castbox.fm/9a/10/70/f6f71dbb19ea20992734c89bf6cbe14428_scaled_v1_400.jpg)
![130 [S10 E2] "Whenever I fell, autism caught me": autism, intersex and gender 130 [S10 E2] "Whenever I fell, autism caught me": autism, intersex and gender](https://s3.castbox.fm/83/c4/c9/93ffb86562726d2357273bb9c4258d9c92_scaled_v1_400.jpg)
![129 [S10 E1] "I thought I was just disorders": navigating autistic and ADHD traits and challenges - with Mrs AuDHD 129 [S10 E1] "I thought I was just disorders": navigating autistic and ADHD traits and challenges - with Mrs AuDHD](https://s3.castbox.fm/a3/ab/5f/aaa60067dedf6f80e1e1fe66cd5c50abba_scaled_v1_400.jpg)





![113 [S9 E8] Making the invisible visible: getting comfortable with a late autism diagnosis 113 [S9 E8] Making the invisible visible: getting comfortable with a late autism diagnosis](https://s3.castbox.fm/40/97/69/9b61ebabed8f904a8548f6778c3f6d2a76_scaled_v1_400.jpg)
![112 [S9 E7] Why the system is thwarting autistic people: reimagining neurodivergent health - with Dr Mel Houser 112 [S9 E7] Why the system is thwarting autistic people: reimagining neurodivergent health - with Dr Mel Houser](https://s3.castbox.fm/24/59/70/94ebf1fcd5928f1d1a18a904553e20007b_scaled_v1_400.jpg)
![111 [S9 E6] A magnet pulling me out of darkness: thinking through my body into autistic expression 111 [S9 E6] A magnet pulling me out of darkness: thinking through my body into autistic expression](https://s3.castbox.fm/bc/0d/81/bea4a17a6c5198ae292820350e00cb041c_scaled_v1_400.jpg)


